The proposed calibration technique provides an efficient approach to eliminating systematic bias in a case crossover study. We used the case crossover design to systematically assess whether the reported triggers occurred more often before fmf attacks than they did in the attackfree periods. The casecrossover design, introduced by maclure 1 in 1991, represents an attractive method to investigate the acute effects of an exposure. Maclure 1991 introduced the casecrossover design as a tool for inferring associations between mortality and exposure using such retrospectively sampled, withinsubject measurements. Controller medication use and sleep problems in pediatric. Analysis of recurrent event data under the casecrossover design 5 and cons of the above methods are discussed in section 3 and then compared in a simulation study in section 4. In a case cross over design all subjects are cases and exposure is measured in two different periods of time. In this article, case crossover studies are treated as cohort studies in which each subject is observed for a short period of time before andor after the event, thus making possible analyzing with andersengill and generalized linear mixed models. This approach compares exposures during the period of time of death case period with one or more periods when death did not occur control periods and evaluates. The casecrossover design represents an attempt to achieve the ideal, but unattainable, design of studying a group of subjects exposed to a particular. The case crossover design is widely used for analysing shortterm pollution exposure with acute outcomes.
A casecontrol design involving only cases may be used when brief exposure causes a. Smeeth l, donnan pt, cook dg 2006 the use of primary care databases. Although this approach controls for timeinvariant confounders by design, it may allow for selection bias and confounding by timevarying factors. Developed by maclure in 1991, the case crossover design provides a means of studying the effects of transient exposure on the risk of acute outcome. Jinseob kim analysis of timeseries data july 17, 2015 7 30 8. The term crossover is applied for designs that all subjects pass through both treatment exposure and placebo nonexposure phases. Create a file for external citation management software. Case crossover and case timecontrol designs as alternatives in pharmacoepidemiologic research. It is a variant of casecontrol and subjectasowncontrol research designs, involving use of information about exposure history of each case to estimate the transient eff. It has been used, for example, to investigate triggers of myocardial infarction. A casecrossover study of alcohol consumption, meals and the.
Here the case, a collision at noon today, was exposed to a hazard, such as a puddle or cell phone call shaded ellipse. An exposure window is a unit of observation associated with the hypothesis being explored. The casecrossover design via penalized regression bmc medical. In this article, casecrossover studies are treated as cohort studies in which each subject is observed for a short period of time before andor after the event, thus making possible analyzing with andersengill and generalized linear mixed models. The case crossover design is useful for assessing the effects of exposures just. Casecrossover design is a variation of casecontrol design that it employs persons history periods as controls. Analysis of casecrossover designs using longitudinal. Sep 25, 2019 referent selection in casecrossover analyses of acute health effects of air pollution. Instead of using timeseries analysis, the casecrossover study design developed by maclure 3 was applied to evaluate the association between daily death counts and air pollution. Case crossover and casetimecontrol designs as alternatives in pharmacoepidemiologic research. Shortterm effects of ozone air pollution on ischaemic.
Characteristic confounding that is constant within one person can be well controlled with this method. Potential for bias in casecrossover studies with shared. The design resembles a retrospective nonrandomized crossover study but. Crossover design sw generally speaking crossover design software combines loudspeaker spl responses that we have previously measured with filter circuit data also defined by us, the designers. Objective to determine the effect of asthma controller medication use, choice, and adherence on sleep in children with asthma design a casecrossover analysis examining withinsubject differences in controller use between time points with and without sleep problems, based on survey data from 3 time points baseline, 6 months, and 1 year of a randomized trial. Confounders in timeseries regression columbia public health. Design, setting, and participants case crossover design and conditional logistic regression to estimate the association between shortterm exposures to pm 2. Analysis of recurrent event data under the case crossover design 5 and cons of the above methods are discussed in section 3 and then compared in a simulation study in section 4. Is zolpidem associated with increased risk of fractures in. The design was illustrated by the research question of whether there is an acutely elevated risk of myocardial infarction mi in connection with sexual activity.
Such analyses may exhibit biases and a lower statistical efficiency than traditional time series analyzed with poisson. Risk of ischemic stroke with the use of risperidone. Association of shortterm exposure to air pollution with. Risk estimates are based on withinsubject comparisons of exposures at failure times with exposures at times prior. We used a timestratified casecrossover study design, which was proposed by maclure for the study of transient effects on the risk of acute events. Casecrossover design can be viewed as the hybrid of casecontrol study and crossover design. The effects of particulate air pollution on daily deaths.
Triggers for attacks in familial mediterranean fever. Casecrossover analyses of air pollution exposure data. This article describes and evaluates caseonly designs for surveillance with administrative databases. This study aims at investigating the association between alcohol and meal consumption and the risk of rtcs using intrapersonal comparisons of subjects while driving. Methods and materials elderly enrollees n 6010 in taiwans national health insurance research database with zolpidem or benzodiazepine use were analyzed for the risk of developing. Interpretation and bias in casecrossover studies journal of clinical. The case crossover design via penalized regression. The casecrossover study design in pharmacoepidemiology. In 1991, maclure proposed the casecrossover design, which can eliminate the bias in control selection by casecontrol design and remove the confounding effects of the factors that are constant over time. The associations were stronger in men than in women.
The casecrossover design described by maclure has recently been used as an alternative to time series analysis. A case control design involving only cases may be used when brief exposure causes a transient change in risk of a rare acuteonset. The casecrossover design is an attractive alternative to the classical case control design which can be used to study the onset of acute events if the risk factors of interest vary. A method for studying transient effects on the risk of acute events malcolm maclure a case control design involving only cases may be used when brief exposure causes a transient change in risk of a rare acuteonset disease. By searching pubmed in april 2016 searching strategy. The referent selection strategy is important for reasons in addition to control of confounding. The casecrossover design was developed to study timevarying exposures that cause transient excess risk of acute health events. In conclusion, systematic bias in a case crossover design is often unavoidable, leading to an obvious bias in the estimated effect and an unreliable p value in the significance test. Selection bias and confounding in casecrossover analyses. Anger was associated with injury in this study primarily at higher levels of anger. We investigated the association between air pollution and infant mortality using a casecrossover design, a technique developed by maclure 1991 that combines features of the crossover design and the matched casecontrol design. Soundeasy v23 loudspeaker design software with usb key.
The proposed calibration technique provides an efficient approach to eliminating systematic bias in a casecrossover study. Application of a timestratified casecrossover design to. Analysis of casecrossover designs using longitudinal approaches. We present the applications of the above methods to the elderly falls data in section 5.
This design is sensitive to the effects of timevarying risk factors. The general principle is to find an answer to the question. Pdf application of the casecrossover design to reduce. This page briefly describes casecrossover designs as an approach to investigating. We used a timestratified case crossover study design, which was proposed by maclure for the study of transient effects on the risk of acute events. Methods we conducted a casecontrol and casecrossover study in all 3 emergency departments in 1 county in missouri. A method for studying transient effects on the risk of acute events. This design is, however, highly sensitive to assumptions about intermittency of drug use and the length of the exposure time window, as demonstrated with the example of bleeding associated with warfarin use. Case cross over studies are the case control version of crossover studies. Lumley t, levy d 2000 bias in the case crossover design. Comparison of time series and casecrossover analyses of. The use of the casecrossover design in studying illicit. Sharma pgims, rohtak which is a tertiary care hospital having 1700 beds and it is one of the premier institutes of haryana. The case crossover design developed by maclure in 1991, the case crossover design provides a means of studying the effects of transient exposure on the risk of acute outcome.
The first decade of experience with casecrossover studies has shown that the design applies best if the exposure is intermittent, the effect on risk is immediate and transient, and the outcome is abrupt. Since then, the case crossover design has become increasingly popular in medical literature. The design utilizes each subject as his or her own control. Maclure proposed the casecrossover design in 1991 3. A graph of risk over time, after patients start a regular exercise program. I also know individuals gender, and it is the effect associated with gender on. The casecrossover design was developed by m aclure 7 to study effects of transient shortterm exposures on the risk of acute events, such as mi in the early 1990s. Application of the casecrossover design to reduce unmeasured confounding in studies of condom effectiveness article pdf available in american journal of epidemiology 1618. The casecrossover analysis results have shown a larger ci in comparison to the results of the timeseries analysis, while the lag days were easier to identify with the casecrossover design. We applied the sensitivity analysis of 7, 14, 30, 60, and 90day exposure windows according to the variable latent period between 5 and 90 days. By comparing exposures within cases at different time periods, the casecrossover design does not rely on control subjects which can be difficult to acquire. In this design a person acts as their own control and hence the potential for between. Jul 28, 2019 the passive crossover designer 8 is a crossover simulation and speaker design tool built into an excel spreadsheet.
This reduces the influence of confounding covariates. In this study design, exposure of each patient to psychological stress during defined hazard periods was compared with control periods. On the equivalence of casecrossover and time series methods in environmental. The first decade of experience with case crossover studies has shown that the design applies best if the exposure is intermittent, the effect on risk is immediate and transient, and the outcome is abrupt. The case crossover design is useful for assessing the effects of exposures just before. The design tool has now been expanded to include a box model, an impedance modeler, and a full active crossover design section for each driver that can be used along with the passive crossover features if desired. In the casecrossover design maclure, 1991, american journal of epidemiology 3, 144153, only cases are sampled, and risk estimates are based on withinsubject comparisons of exposures at.
In conclusion, the case crossover design is potentially a powerful approach to assess the risk of drugs. Referent selection in casecrossover analyses of acute health effects of air pollution. Raw data and software that are available online are also referenced. In these studies, cases and controls are the same subjects. Methods and results the association between ohca and air pollution concentrations hours and days before onset was assessed by using a timestratified casecrossover design using 11 677 emergency medical servicelogged ohca events between 2004 and 2011 in houston, texas. Prescription data on whether individuals have a given prescription at time 1 yesno and time 2 yesno. However, while casecontrol designs select control individuals, casecrossover designs select control time windows. In the case crossover design maclure, 1991, american journal of epidemiology 3, 144153, only cases are sampled, and risk estimates are based on withinsubject comparisons of exposures at. To answer this question for all cases, a control group is. The case crossover design is also accurate in drug epidemiology, at lower cost than case control studies, as long as the case series is recorded independently of the exposure status. The casecrossover design provides an ideal method for quantifying the increased risk due to transient exposure to triggers 7, 8. Recently casecrossover design has been applied as a complementary or alternative approach for studying effects of shortterm exposure to air pollution 8, 9. Figure 1 the relation of the simplest case crossover design to a traditional matchedpair case control design.
This paper also highlights the importance in identifying and controlling for confounding, selection bias, and autocorrelation. This design was developed to study the effects of shortterm exposures on the risk of acute events. The casecrossover design via penalized regression bmc. Concepts design if average air pollution of controls case crossover study design is a popular analytic tool for estimating the effects of triggers of acute outcomes by environmental exposures. Pediatric psychiatric emergency department utilization and. Does air pollution trigger infant mortality in western.
Assessing the shortterm effects of heatwaves on mortality. Nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs as a risk factor for. On casecrossover methods for environmental time series data. The casecrossover cc design has proved effective to investigate the association between alcohol use and injuries in general, but has never been applied to study alcohol use and road traffic crashes rtcs specifically. Something that the casecrossover design has in common with a casecontrol approach is the need to find representative controls. However, this design has been used to study single changes in exposure level, gradual effects on risk, and outcomes with insidious onsets.
In the matchedpair casecrossover design, the control is the same person at a different. A casecontrol design involving only cases may be used when brief exposure causes a transient change in risk of a rare acuteonset. In a traditional matchedpair casecontrol study, the control is a different person at a similar time. The case crossover design represents an attempt to achieve the ideal, but unattainable, design of studying a group of subjects exposed to a particular event, activity, or influence, and also studying exactly the same subjects during the same period when not exposed to it. Malcolm maclure professor and bc chair in patient safety. Maclure m, mittleman ma 2000 should we use a casecrossover design. A method for studying transient effects on the risk of acute events malcolm maclure a casecontrol design involving only cases may be used when brief exposure causes a transient change in risk of a rare acuteonset disease.
Eliminating systematic bias from casecrossover designs. Casecrossover design in air pollution epidemiology. Pdf the casecrossover design via penalized regression. The objective of this presentation is to illustrate the principles of casecrossover design by comparing it with crossover and casecontrol designs. A casecrossover study of alcohol consumption, meals and. On the equivalence of case crossover and time series methods in environmental. The study included the entire medicare population from january 1, 2000, to.
A case crossover analysis is a variant of the case control in which each subject serves as her or his own control. They used the casecrossover to study the hypothesis that incidence of myocardial infarctions heart attacks are in. In conclusion, systematic bias in a casecrossover design is often unavoidable, leading to an obvious bias in the estimated effect and an unreliable p value in the significance test. On casecrossover methods for environmental time series. The casecrossover design is an attractive alternative to the classical. The innovative casecrossover study design is a hybrid design. In casecrossover and casecontrol analyses, respectively, odds ratios for the answer extremely were 4. The study was conducted between july 2007 and may 2008 in yerevan, armenia. Acute psychological stress is a trigger for stroke. Bidirectional casecrossover studies of air pollution.
The casecrossover design is an attractive alternative to the classical casecontrol design which can be used to study the onset of acute events if the risk factors of interest vary in time. Casecrossover studies are the casecontrol version of crossover studies. Aug 22, 2016 the casecrossover design is an attractive alternative to the classical casecontrol design which can be used to study the onset of acute events if the risk factors of interest vary in time. The casecrossover design was first introduced by maclure 24 and is used increasingly in the literature to assess episodic events following shortterm exposure to air pollution. The casecrossover design is used to evaluate associations between transient exposures and the onset of acute events. This allows for the prediction simulation of overall speaker spl responses which in turn verify whether design targets have been achieved or not. The design resembles a retrospective nonrandomized crossover study but differs in having only a sample of the base populationtime. However, this design has been used to study single changes in exposure level, gradual effects o.
Background we conducted a study using a casecrossover design to clarify the risk of acute effects of zolpidem and benzodiazepine on allsites of fractures in the elderly. A casecontrol design involving only cases may be used when brief exposure causes a transient change in risk of a rare acuteonset disease. Analysis of recurrent event data under the casecrossover. The casecrossover study design is a popular analytic tool for estimating the effects of triggers of acute outcomes by environmental exposures. The length of the hazard period was chosen based on maclure and mittlemans suggestion i. The simplest casecrossover design is closely analogous to a traditional matchedpair casecontrol design. Maclures 56 casecrossover design paper proposed using cases as their own controls but assigning a different exposure period to the same cases that were also. In response to these limitations, the casecrossover design was first developed by maclure in 1991 2. A bidirectional casecrossover design was used to examine the association between air pollutants and stroke onset maclure, 25 jaakkola 26. Even more important in the air pollution setting is that timevarying confounders can also be controlled by design by matching referents to the index time.
Timeinvariant confounders are controlled by making withinsubject comparisons. The case crossover design is used to evaluate associations between transient exposures and the onset of acute events. Since then, the casecrossover design has become increasingly popular in medical literature. In the case crossover design each case acts as hisher own control and therefore interpersonal confounding for factors that do not vary suddenly with time is eliminated. Nested casecrossover designs in other epi demiological studies. In response to these limitations, the case crossover design was first developed by maclure in 1991 2. We sought to define further the relationship between state anger and risk of injury. Approximate bayesian inference for casecrossover models. Analysis of case crossover designs using longitudinal approaches.
Figueiras a, carracedomartinez e, saez m, taracido m. In one common implementation of this design, each subjects exposure before a casedefining event case period is compared with his or her own exposure experience during 1 or more control periods in which the subject did not become a case. Casecrossover studies of occupational trauma injury prevention. In one common implementation of this design, each subjects exposure before a case defining event case period is compared with his or her own exposure experience during 1 or more control periods in which the subject did not become a case. Design, setting, and participants casecrossover design and conditional logistic regression to estimate the association between shortterm exposures to pm 2. In the casecrossover design, we set four reference windows with the same duration before the recent window.
1119 346 1607 978 1112 100 1530 163 1605 1582 647 1618 718 1522 350 1447 393 580 604 1250 1370 463 677 253 1563 292 869 118 565 706 1281 1212 709 1419 296 186 825 1499 121 418 1309 1475 962 1298 763 936 1356 1157